For most Americans, buying a home means taking out a mortgage loan. The Dodd-Frank Act requires us to combine the Truth in Lending Act and Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act disclosures. You receive these disclosures shortly after you apply for a mortgage and shortly before you close on the mortgage. We decided to involve the people who will actually use the new forms—consumers, lenders, mortgage brokers, settlement agents—in helping to combine and improve them.
These are the results.
On this page
The new disclosures
Our new disclosures are easier to understand and use than the existing disclosures. In addition, the Loan Estimate you get after you apply for a mortgage and the Closing Disclosure you get before you close are designed to work with each other. Take a look at them side by side to see how they’re different.
The disclosure forms compared above are for common mortgage loan transactions. Here are new disclosures forms for other uses:
What makes the new disclosures better
To be sure the Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure are easier to use and understand than the existing forms, we tested them in a quantitative validation study. Participants provided more correct answers about a sample mortgage using the new forms than they did using the current forms.
We’ve annotated the front page of the new Loan Estimate below with a few examples of some of the differences. On the form itself, click on any of the sections from this list to learn more about how it helps consumers: what it means and/or what we learned about it from testing.
Loan Amount | Interest Rate | Estimated Total Monthly Payment | Estimated Closing Costs | Website URL
Using existing forms, 61 percent of survey respondents could say what the loan amount was. Using the new forms, that number jumped to 99 percent. When the amount changed from the Loan Estimate to the Closing Disclosure, we saw greater than 30 percent improvements in knowing not only that the amount had changed but also why it had changed.
Interest RateMost respondents got the year one interest rate right with the current disclosures, though slightly more got it right with our new ones (92.1 vs. 96.7 percent). Roughly the same number (about 93 percent in both cases) could say whether the interest rate could change. The new forms excelled on timing: 90 percent could say when the rate could change, up from 81 percent. Finally, roughly the same number of people using the new forms could tell that the principle and interest change could change over time (from 90 percent to 89 percent).
Estimated Closing Costs
When we asked for “estimated settlement charges,” the new disclosure performed worse. The new forms use different language (the more common “closing costs,” not “settlement charges”). But when it comes to comparing, our disclosures are easier to use. When we asked whether settlement charges had changed from the Loan Estimate to a corresponding Closing Disclosure, far more people accurately noted there were changes with the new forms than with the current forms.
Estimated Total Monthly Payment
68 percent of respondents correctly noted the first month’s payment using the new disclosures. Well under half the respondents could do so using the existing ones.
Find more about the specific changes to Regulations X and Z on our TILA-RESPA rule page. For more about the testing results and methods, see the bottom of this page.
How we did it
The Dodd-Frank Act required the CFPB to integrate existing mortgage disclosure forms to improve compliance and help people understand their loans. We started the Know Before You Owe project for mortgage disclosures to get a wide array of feedback as we designed the prototypes for the new forms. Here’s a timeline of how the project developed.
You can also read reports below on the testing and other related subjects.
The final rule
We issued the final rule on November 20, 2013. See the rule and learn more about what it means for industry.
Learn more about mortgages
»Testing disclosure prototypes before issuing the proposed rule
»Qualitative testing of the new disclosures for a refinancing loan, for both English- and Spanish-speakers
»A quantitative validation study of the new disclosures that are included in the final rule
»A report on our discussions with small businesses